Disney’s Mulan

 

 

 

 

mulan powerful

 

 

Disney’s “Mulan” was released in 1998 and remains as one of Disney’s classic children’s movies. Mulan takes place in Imperial China during the invasion of the Huns over the recently constructed Great Wall. The movie follows the journey of Fa Mulan, the only child of a respected war hero. During the initial invasions, Mulan is struggling to bring honour to her father and family, by becoming a respectable woman who will soon find a husband. After failing yet again at fitting into society’s cookie cut out of a perfect Chinese woman, Mulan returns home to soon find that the Emperor has released letters of conscription to each family. Since Mulan is the only child in the Fa family, and female, her father is forced to enlist in the war. However, he is injured from his first time serving and as a result is weak and requires a cane to walk. Therefore, in order to save her father, Mulan changes her appearance by cutting her hair off and sets off to fight for China in her father’s place. The story thus follows Mulan’s struggles of being a woman in a man’s world, leading to her ultimate triumph of being the one to save the Emperor, and China, from the Huns.

The basis of Mulan’s story revolves around one the largest forms of cultural hegemony, and one that is still predominately seen in the East today. This cultural hegemony is the equality struggle between men and women. From the beginning of the movie, gender roles are very clearly distinguished. Although this further enhances Mulan’s ultimate triumph, it negatively feeds into the cultural hegemony of the movie.
mulan tight waist
Mulan’s character is introduced as being a failure to her family up to this point in her life. The first scene shows Mulan studying for her meeting with the town’s matchmaker. In order for Mulan to bring honour to her family, she must do well on this interview so that she will be married to a respectable man. As Mulan goes over the qualities a woman should have she recites: “quiet, graceful, delicate, polite, poise, punctual.” This is an example of pop culture’s stereotype for how a woman should behave. To further this stereotype, as she is being prepared for her interview the workers sing to her: “men want girls with good taste, calm, obedient, who work fast past, with good breeding and a tiny waste…you’ll bring honour to us all.” As the workers dress Mulan they pull her belt tight, clearly making Mulan uncomfortable, but emphasizing her petite figure. We watched a part of Jean Kilbourne’s “Killing Us Softly” in lecture four, and discussed the way pop culture and the media discuss body image. With regards to Mulan, it is clear that the importance lies on her physical qualities and essentially what she will be able to offer a husband. The comments on Mulan’s size however, do not end there. When Mulan meets the matchmaker, the first thing she says while evaluating her is “too skinny, not good for bearing sons.” Not only does this completely objectify Mulan as a baby-making machine, but also the importance of the message is once again brought back to Mulan’s physical qualities. Jean Kilbourne explains how in the eyes of the media we are never good enough. This holds to be true in the portrayal of Mulan. First she is told to be skinny and then put down as being too skinny. The message being sent to young children, and young girls for that matter is completely absurd. Rather than enforcing body image as a positive aspect, this movie tells children who are in the stage of developing self-image that they will never be good enough.
mulanmulan beauty
The cultural hegemony in Mulan is depicted through the idea of honour. By Mulan being a female, any of her actions that are not considered culturally acceptable automatically bestow dishonor on her father. When Mulan interrupts the conscription announcement in her first attempt to save her father, the Emperor’s assistant tells Mulan’s father: “you would do well to teach your daughter to hold her tongue in a man’s presence.” Mulan is constantly told that she must learn her place, even by her father, who although loves Mulan, is still embarrassed by her actions. As a female, Mulan will never have the same social power or respect as a man. This can also be seen when Mulan is revealed to her fellow soldiers and captain as being a woman. Although Mulan saved the entire team and was even wounded in the process, as soon as she is revealed to be a female all respect for her is lost. The captain was in fact supposed to kill Mulan for her actions, causing “high treason! Ultimate dishonor!” However, he spares her life since she just saved his. Nevertheless, Mulan loses all credit for her brave actions that saved the Imperial army. Thankfully, her honour is restored in the end of the movie when she saves the Emperor (as a female) alongside her fellow soldiers.
mulan shame
At one point, Mulan makes her fellow soldiers dress up as women to distract the guards. When the guards see them they mutter “concubines” to each other. Ironically, concubines in Imperial China were women contracted to men as secondary wives. These women had lower social status and rights, thus, another depiction of woman as a secondary class to men.
concubines in mulan
In lecture five we discussed the novels “50 Shades of Grey” and “Twilight” and examined common qualities between the two. Mulan also follows these characteristics. For example, characteristics of the males are dominance, competitiveness, and physical prowess. In contrast, Mulan is self-sacrificing, clumsy, empathetic, and has anxiety about her beauty. Overall, Mulan, like the books analyzed in lecture, ends with a happy marriage and peace.
mulan love

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “Disney’s Mulan

  1. I always get upset analyzing Disney movies because they hold a special spot in my heart; however, many, if not all have huge problems especially with sexism and racism! Mulan is just one example. I always thought that Disney created this movie to try and send a positive message, such as women can do anything that men can do, but by doing so, it belittled the “traditional” roles of women. Mulan literally has to fight and win a war to get any respect from the men and women within her community. Bearing children, being a stay at home mom, etc. is not good enough or respectable. Also, in respect to the comment Mulan’s matchmaker said about too skinny to bear sons, demonstrates the hierarchy between men and women. In addition, I believe Disney was playing into racist stereotypes about Asian families, which is also extremely problematic.

  2. I know exactly what you mean! It’s so easy and catchy to sing along to the songs and remember watching the movie as a kid. I was easily singing the song “Make a Man out of you” and then I stopped and realized the content of the song and thought to myself “hmmn maybe I should be analyzing this for my gender blog..”

  3. As eeyorehastheblues stated, I hate analyzing Disney movies that I have grown up with, but to be rather honest, Disney movies have more to them just what is shown. You stated somewhere, that “the importance lies on her physical qualities and essentially what she will be able to offer a husband.” This is absolutely true. Mulan as to go through so many obstacles to just prove to the male characters that she is worthy of something and that she might even be better at things than others. You stated that media considers Mulan to be skinny/too skinny and that is sending the wrong message to children. Personally, I do not agree with media (as I often see myself in this position). It might send the wrong message to children, but at the end of the day, it is also how the children interpret the movie.

  4. Like everyone above has stated, Disney also played a pretty meaningful part in my childhood. Looking back as a child, I don’t think I’d ever realize many of these [negative] messages that were being demonstrated in Mulan (let alone many other Disney productions, i.e., Pocahontas). Although, that’s probably a good thing I missed some of those. However, one thing that doesn’t really need to be read into with detail, but stands out like a giant target is this need to find some man with whom to marry and make a family with–and to do so, you need have fallen under those specific categories, as listed in their catchy song. Obviously, this instills some pretty problematic notions in the minds of young, impressionable children (i.e., the target audience). No wonder so many girls have this awful impression that they need to have a certain physique and personality if they want a man to marry them…

  5. Growing up Mulan was one of my favourite movies, it showed that there was always a choice to go against the norm and prove yourself. The movie demonstrates the idea of gender roles, male dominance and patriarchy. Growing up i never saw it like this, but showing that the norm is male dominant and that Mulan as a female is going against society by being a powerful woman it is true that this can have detrimental effect on developing, easily influenced youth. Disney has been known to enforce stereotypes and hegemonic cultural views in many of their early movies in relation to other cultures and Mulan is no different. I enjoyed reading this, I always find articles analysing things I grew up with extremely interesting!

  6. I loved Mulan as a kid and now I still find it hard to say a bad thing about it but your critique makes some very valid points. The matchmaker scene is very “2nd wave feminism backlash” in that society uses fear tactics to essentially tell women that if they do not look and act a specific “feminine” way then they won’t be able to find a man and they will end up alone. However, I always viewed Mulan as an inspirational character for proving herself worthy of respect despite the odds and expectations of society. I never thought about it the way eeyorehastheblues did in that this movie does belittle the unpaid work of women who may choose to stay home and manage households or raise children. In fact, the lack of respect, appreciation and value given to domestic work is a problem that persists. This relates to the Mommy-blaming theory we looked at in GNDS 125 lecture. Women may want to go out into the workforce and stay involved in academics further into life but they are simultaneously expected to do all of the caregiving – practically a second full time job but without the pay or esteem it deserves.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s